Federal judges refuse to rule on right to die case

The Federal Court has refused to rule on a case of a Geneva doctor who helped a healthy elderly woman to die in 2017.

Dr Pierre Beck says he acted in good faith when he prescribed a fatal dose of drugs to the 86-year-old who had told him she didn’t want to live after the death of her husband, who was terminally ill. 

The doctor says he decided the woman had full capacity to make the decision. 

He’s been convicted of breaking the law by a Geneva court and given a suspended fine. 

But he’s appealed to try to force the courts to accept it could be possible in some circumstances to help someone end their life, even if they are physically healthy.

Federal judges have ordered the lower court to reconsider.

The doctor says he pleased with the decision, even if the long running case is not over. 

He says it means the Federal Court has not ruled out the possibility of assisting the elderly to die if they choose to. 

More from Bitesize News

  • Crans Montana hearings continue

    The former Crans-Montana councillor in charge of security between 2017 and 2020 has been questioned for the first time by Valais prosecutors over the Constellation fire on New Year's Day

  • SBB need financial answers

    Federal Railways have backed Transport Minister Albert Rösti's Transport'45 plan but warn that current funding is not enough to deliver its promised upgrades

  • UNHCR warning

    Geneva-based UNHCR warns that shrinking international aid could leave 8.3 million refugees and displaced people without protection this year

  • New immigration tax

    The Upper house has voted to introduce a new incentive tax on immigration, going further than the Federal Council proposed

  • Fuel most expensive in the country

    Fuel prices between Lausanne and Geneva differ by only a few centimes, and Lake Geneva remains the most expensive region in Switzerland to fill up

  • Twint scam warning

    Switzerland has launched a national campaign to help the public spot online scams that exploit the Twint payment app

Download our app

  • Available on the App Store
  • Available on Google Play